5 Ways to Decide Between Bathtub Refinishing and Bathtub Replacement

It is the most common question asked by the homeowners whether they should go for the bathtub refinishing or to replace the entire bathtub. If you are among them, then this article is just for you.

Bathtub Refinishing and bathtub replacement are the two potential options that stand before us when it comes to updating the look of your bathroom.  However, both are convenient choices for the homeowners each have its shortcoming. If you are confused between bathtub Refinishing and Bathtub replacement, then you can go through these points to make your decision.

Worn out bathtub

Has your bathtub seen good years of luster, and it no longer flaunts the same finish? Well, then you need to think about updating it. In this case, you can go for a bathtub replacement. It will not only ensure a fresh look in your bathroom but enhance the lifestyle and comfort. If your bathtub is beyond repairs, then the cost of repairs could exceed the cost of a new one. Therefore, make a conscious choice.

Severity of Damage

Certain bathtub materials like cast iron, steel, and fiberglass can be refinished easily and save you on costly bathtub replacements. However, if the tub has unrelenting dents, rust, and noticeably damaged areas that can’t be repaired, then replacement is the only choice.  In order to determine the severity of the bathtub damage, you will need to consult an expert. The expert will help in analyzing whether the dents and the scratches can be treated or you will require a bathtub replacement.


When it comes to deciding between bathtub refinishing and bathtub replacement in terms of cost, then bathtub refinishing is the best option to go. Not everyone has a big budget to transform the look of the bathroom. In such a case, bathtub refinishing emerges as a potential alternative to replacement. If you decide to go with the replacement option, you will need to incur more than refinishing.

The cost of bathtub replacement will entail replacing the old bathtub, installing the new one, re-installing the fixtures due to inconvenience. If you find it all overwhelming, bathtub refinishing is the option for you.  The cost of bathtub refinishing may vary according to the size of the bathtub and the material used, but it certainly is a cost-effective option to replace.


The bathtub refinishing process is a matter of a few hours. After the refinishing process, you will need to handle the tub with care for quite good days to ensure it last for the years to come. In opposition to this, tub replacement is more of a time-consuming process.  You will need to get the old tub removed and install the new one in its place. It is a messy process and can be overwhelming too. Refinishing is a matter of a few hours, and the tub is ready to use after it dries up completely. You can choose between minimizing the time consumption and improving the ambiance by installing the new bathtub.

Replacing the Tub Surrounds

When you are deciding between tub replacements and refinishing, tub surround is a crucial parameter in making the right choice. Replacing the bathtub will require replacement of the surrounding tiles too. If you have purchased a bathtub of different sizes and styles, you will need the tiles that align with it perfectly. Whereas, with bathtub refinishing, you can get the tiles refinished as well. Guess what! You don’t even need to replace the bathtub for it!

By now, you must have made up your mind! Bathtub refinishing is the best alternative to replacement. Confusion is natural when it comes to updating the space; consult the best Bathtub Refinishing Buffalo Ny expert to make a sound decision.